BEST ENGINES OF ALLTIME
Most car engines today are pretty similar. Even the ones we’d call different, like Porsche’s flat-sixes or Fiat’s new two-cylinder, follow tried-and-true engineering maxims that have dominated the industry for the past 50 years. But not every car manufacturer plays by the rules when designing engines. Some of the nonconformist engines are just weird enough to raise an eyebrow, but a small number are completely off-the-wall, shirt-eating, stranger-hugging insane. Sometimes there was a method to the madness, such as trying to improve efficiency. Other times, it was clear the inmates got the run of the engineering department. And we’re just fine with that.
To put together our list of 10 crazy car engines, we followed some rules: production passenger-vehicle powerplants only; no racing mills or one-off experiments, because those are weird by definition. We also left off engines that distinguish themselves solely by being the first or largest of something. That’s because the goal here is to emphasize the kind of crazy engine design that makes your brain hurt.
So let’s fire em up.
 |
The stats are the stuff of legend: The Bug’s 8.0-liter, 1000-plus-hp W-16 is the most powerful and complex production engine in history. It has 64 valves, four turbochargers, and enough pavement-shredding grunt—922 lb-ft at 2200 rpm—to wrinkle God’s underwear. Its W-shaped, 16-cylinder layout, essentially an orgy of narrow-angle Volkswagen VR4s, has never been used before and likely never will be again. Oh, and it comes with a warranty.
This is a once-in-a-lifetime engineering unicorn, kind of like what would happen if the Apollo space program and Ferdinand Porsche somehow jointly got the Titanic pregnant. If that ain’t interesting, we don’t know what is.
 |
At the beginning of the past century, automotive frontiersman Charles Yale Knight had an epiphany. Traditional poppet valves, he reasoned, were too complicated, the attendant springs and followers too inefficient. His solution was dubbed the sleeve valve—a sliding sleeve around the piston, driven by a geared shaft, which exposed intake and exhaust ports in the cylinder wall.
Amazingly, it worked. Sleeve-valve engines offered high volumetric efficiency, low noise, and no risk of valve float; disadvantages were few but included high oil consumption. Knight patented his idea in 1908, and it later appeared in everything from Mercedes-Benzes to Panhards and Peugeots. The technology fell out of favor when poppet valves became better able to cope with heat and high rpm.
 |
Imagine that you’re a 1950s carmaker being pitched an experimental engine. This German dude named Felix walks into your office and tries to sell you on the idea of a three-pointed piston spinning around inside an oval box, burning fuel as it goes. It looks like a ball of fire in a bingo cage, or maybe a football knocking around in a washing machine. And not only does it run, but it’s also incredibly balanced.
The rotor itself is triangular with convex faces, and its three corners are called apexes. As the rotor spins within the housing, it creates three chambers that are responsible for the four phases of the power cycle: intake, compression, power, and exhaust. Each face of the rotor is always at work on one stage of the cycle. If it sounds efficient, that’s because it is—sort of. Horsepower outputs are high relative to engine displacement, but they suck fuel like whoa because the combustion chamber is elongated.
Weird stuff, no? You know what’s weirder? It’s still in production. Buy a Mazda RX-8, and you can have a 9000-rpm Wankel engine for yourself! What are you waiting for? Get off the couch!
 |
Connecticut’s Eisenhuth Horseless Vehicle Company was formed by John Eisenhuth, a New York man who claimed to have invented the gasoline engine and had a nasty habit of getting sued by his business partners. His 1904–07 Compound models featured an inline three-cylinder engine where two outer cylinders powered an unignited, “dead” middle cylinder with their exhaust gases; the middle cylinder provided the engine’s output. The outer cylinders were huge, with 7.5-inch bores, but the inner, at 12 inches across, was larger still. Eisenhuth claimed a 47-percent increase in fuel economy over a standard engine of similar size. He also went bankrupt in 1907. Go figure.
 |
Leave it to the French to design an interesting engine that seems ordinary at first glance. Famed Gallic manufacturer Panhard, largely remembered for its eponymous suspension rod, powered its postwar cars with a series of air-cooled, aluminum-block boxers. They were distinguished by unit construction—the block and the cylinder head were one casting—torsion-bar valve springs, a roller-bearing crank, hollow aluminum pushrods, and exhaust pipes that doubled as engine mounts on one variant. Displacement varied from 610 cc to 850 cc; output was between 42 hp and 60 hp, depending on model. The best part? The Panhard twin remains the oddest engine ever to notch class wins at the 24 Hours of Le Mans.
 |
Strange name, sure, but the engine is even weirder. The 3.3-liter Commer TS3 was a supercharged, opposed-piston (each cylinder has two pistons with their crowns facing each other, and there are no cylinder heads), single-crankshaft (most opposed-piston engines have two), three-cylinder, two-stroke diesel engine. The Rootes Group dreamed up this beast to power its Commer-branded trucks. The TS3 offered ingenious packaging, connecting-rod rocker arms the size of a small cat, and at 270 lb-ft of torque, more grunt than many larger diesels of the time.
Confused? Watch the animation here.
 |
Think the Commer was smart? This one puts it on the trailer. England’s Lanchester Motor Company was founded in 1899. The firm’s Lanchester Ten, introduced a year later, featured an air-cooled, twin-crankshaft, 4.0-liter flat-twin driving the rear wheels. One crank lived above the other, and each piston had three connecting rods—two light outer ones and a heavier one in the center. The light rods went to one crank, the heavy rods to the other, and the two shafts counterrotated. The result was 10.5 hp at 1250 rpm and a remarkable lack of vibration. If you’ve ever wondered what engineering elegance looks like, this is it.
 |
Like the Veyron, the limited-production Cizeta (née Cizeta-Moroder) V16T supercar is defined by its engine. The 560-hp, 6.0-liter V-16 in the Ciz’s belly isn’t a true V-16. If you go by firing order and construction, it’s merely two flat-plane V-8s sharing a single block and joined by a central timing case. This makes it no less insane. Because the engine is mounted transversely, a central shaft feeds power into a rear-mounted transaxle. The Cizetas are rarer than honest politicians, with just a tiny number built. The true production number is a secret, of course, but one of them occasionally surfaced in L.A., where its owner revved it mercilessly prior to customs officials seizing it in 2009.
 |
The Commer Knocker engine was actually inspired (if that’s the right word) by this French family of opposed-piston engines that were built in two-, four-, and six-cylinder form until the early 1920s. Here’s how it works in two-cylinder guise: Two pistons drive the crankshaft in the conventional manner. Opposing the two pistons is another set of two vertically opposed pistons joined by a crosshead. In turn, this crosshead drives two long connecting rods coupled to the crank at 180 degrees relative to the lower pistons. The opposed pistons effectively form the cylinder heads. A six-cylinder engine thus has 12 pistons and a crank with the torsional rigidity of spaghetti.
The production engines ranged from 2.3-liter twos to 11.4-liter sixes. There was also a monster 13.5-liter four-cylinder racer that was the first car to top 100 mph, driven by Louis Rigolly at Ostend, Belgium, in 1904. These crazy Frenchmen, obviously unfettered by conventional thinking, also ran a crude form of fuel injection in their earliest engines.
 |
If the idea of your engine rotating behind you seems like a good one, then the Adams-Farwell, hailing from Dubuque, Iowa, is your car. Well, it wasn’t the whole engine rotating: just the cylinders and pistons, because the crankshafts on these three- and five-cylinder engines were fixed. Arranged radially, the cylinders were air-cooled and acted as a flywheel once the engine was up and running. Drive was taken off the cylinder assembly via a short, single chain, and the units were light for the time—190 pounds for the 4.3-liter three-cylinder and 265 pounds for the 8.0-liter five.
The cars themselves were rear-engined, with the passenger compartment mounted far forward, perfect for getting absolutely destroyed in an accident. Bearing in mind the lack of mechanical reliability in the early days of motoring, we wonder exactly how comfortable you would feel about 265 pounds whirling at 1000 rpm behind your calves.
 |
 |
Thirty cylinders, five banks, five carburetors, five distributors, 1255 cubic inches. This is what happens when Detroit goes to war. Chrysler built the A57 as a way to satisfy a World War II tank-engine contract in a hurry, using as many off-the-shelf components as possible. It consisted of five 251-cube passenger-car inline-sixes arranged radially around a central output shaft. The resulting 425-hp pile of hairy freedom powered M3A4 Lee and M4A4 Sherman tanks.
 |
Although the mere mention of a racing engine is an automotive Pandora’s box of weirdness, the BRM H-16 is too obnoxious not to mention. BRM’s 3.0-liter, 32-valve H-16, essentially two flat-eights doing the horizontal bop, was the work of designer Tony Rudd. It put out more than 400 hp but was handicapped by weight and reliability. Jim Clark gave the engine its only F1 win, at the 1966 U.S. Grand Prix, and Jackie Stewart once likened it to a boat anchor. It sounded like four Subarus in a mailbox.
This wasn’t the only 16-cylinder engine the BRM lads dabbled with. They also developed a supercharged 1.5-liter V-16. It spun to 12,000 rpm and produced roughly 485 hp. It’d make for one hell of a swap into an AE86 Corolla.
There isn't just one path to a great engine. Different companies have different approaches to evoking emotion and performance from their heavily engineered powerplants. These are the 10 engines that captured the hearts and minds of car nuts everywhere.
10.) Honda K20
This is the point where VTEC kicks in, and it's very yo.
200(ish) HP, 8000+ RPM redline, and smooth up and down the rev range. The lack of low-end torque is more than made up for by the way it begs to be redlined, and loves every minute of it. Easy to make more power with simple bolt-ons and reprogramming, with Honda reliability to boot.
Suggested By: The Stig's Rustbelt Cousin, Photo Credit: Honda
9.) Toyota 1LR-GUE V10
Developed by Yamaha just like the Volvo V8 that powers the Noble M600, this 72-degree 4.8-liter V10 is so rev-happy that you need digital instruments to follow its moves. It also sounds like a well lubricated dream.
The Lexus LFA is worth every penny for this engine alone.
Suggested By: Patrick George, Photo Credit: Wikimedia Commons
8.) AMC 4.0
The first incarnation of AMC's 4.0 straight-six dates back to 1964. I know. But hear me out!
The 4.0 liter version came out in 1986, but was reworked and redesigned all through the 1990s and into the mid 2000s. The one in the picture is full of names because it's the 5 millionth 4.0 engine built produced on the Greenlee Block Line.
A friend had a Comanche with the 4.0. It was a damn beast.I had a Cherokee with the 4.0. What a engine. Goobs of power. It would run with zero fluids in it. I think mine ended up with 200k miles on it. The only thing I ever replaced was belts and plugs.
Dear god yes. I knew five people in college with Cherokees powered by these beasts. The rest of the trucks usually fell apart, but these things never. Fucking. Quit.One even went 23,000 miles, driven hard, with a leaking seal somewhere, without an oil change. Sold it and the new owner rebuilt it, after driving it home 400 miles through a New England winter storm. Incredible.
A legend in its spare time.
Suggested By: jvbftw, Photo Credit: Wikimedia Commons
7.) Alfa Romeo V6 24V
I'm bending the rules again slightly since the quattrovalvole version of the glorious Alfa V6 is 22-years old now, but I agree with Chris. It has to be on the list.
It's one of the most beautiful engines ever made, it sounds fantastic and got the power too. You don't need more.
Suggested By: Chris Perkins, Photo Credit: Wikimedia Commons
6.) Toyota 2JZ-GTE
The 2JZ-GTE with VVT-i was created to fight Nissan's brilliant engines in the world of boost and variable valve-timing. The basic engine debuted in 1991, but its variable-timing version came out in 1997, so it's good after all.
Put a 2JZ-GTE into literally anything, and you'll be good too.
Suggested By: RazoE, Photo Credit: Wikimedia Commons
5.) Buick V6 Series 2 3800
One of GM's big shots. N2Skylark:
Lots of horsepower (for its day), torque, smoothness, durability, and reliability. Back in the day, full-size cars like the LeSabre were rated at 30mpg highway with it.
I've said for some time that if GM could build an entire car as well as they can build an engine, they would rule the world.
Suggested By: N2Skylark, Photo Credit: GM
4.) Volkswagen TFSI
It's supercharged for low-end torque, it's turbocharged for high-end torque and fuel economy, it's compact, light and extremely versatile.
This engine is in everything from the GTI, A3 to the boring Audi Q5, and Tiguan to the iconic Golf R and it can be tuned to insanely high horsepower and return 30mpg in the right hands.
Suggested By: themanwithsauce, Photo Credit: Volkswagen
3.) Ford Ecoboost V6
I am prepared for the backlash, but I firmly believe it: Ford's EcoBoost V6.It has, for the first time in history, given the top truck line a V6 that outperforms the V8s in both horsepower, torque, and MPG. While there may be engines out there that crank out more power than the EcoBoost, none have come close to changing the half ton pick up truck landscape like this motor has. And this is VERY important to meeting CAFE regulations.
I'm supportive.
Suggested By: PatBateman, Photo Credit: Ford
2.) BMW S54
We all want one, right? So that pretty much settles it.
Suggested By: willkinton247, Photo Credit: BMW
1.) GM LS Series
It just works.
#1 1uz-fe
ReplyDelete